I'm stuck between two loves. What should I do?

For genuinely interested people, I present my quite illogical but heart-flustering case. I'm in love with a guy (P) while I love another (V). (Some of you might be wondering how can that be...Read further...you'll come to know...) Both are great friends and I don't want to hurt either of them. This gets complicated because both guys are close friends, best pals to be precise, and the one (V) with whom I have an official relationship is unaware of the dilemma I'm facing but he loves me wholeheartedly. The other one (P) is somewhat closer to me...nearer to my love calling...more suited to be my soulmate..and he is facing the same situation as me. He is also committed before even having met me. We were each other's crush initially and it inevitably turned into a brimming love over the last few months. I can't decide whether to confess the truth to my current legitimate boyfriend..or to let destiny work it out...or to conceal this passionate love. My "soulmate" goodnaturedly soothed me, persuading me to leave it to God. Could anybody help me out? Thank you for your valuable advice :)